2010 Central Street, Evanston, IL
Tues – Sat 7:30am-4pm


The Tag’s Bakery menus are carefully curated with our most delicious and famous items. Our bakers and decorators bring our menu to life with their beautiful, yummy, and carefully crafted creations that are beautifully displayed in our bakery cases and enjoyed at celebrations and in homes.

Bakery Menu


Our signature item for over 50 years! Originally from Vienna, a baked confection made from honey, butter, sugar, and sliced almonds. They are topped with a piece of candied cherry and coated underneath with chocolate. The Florentine recipe was gifted to owner Don Vetter back in the early 70’s from a long-time baker friend. They will be the talk of the party. Florentines are sold by the pound. We also offer them in a small gift package as well as a silver or gold gift box.

Florentines (32-36 per pound) Per Pound $34.50
Small Gift Package (12 count) $15.25
Silver Gift Box (18 count) $19.95
Gold Gift Box (36 Count) $35.75


Butter Cookies $29.50/pound

Wide variety of bite sized, handmade butter cookies, from the simple butter cookie to butter cookies infused with almond paste. Vast assortment of toppings and fillings that vary with the season

Smiley Face Cookie $3.19

A customer favorite! Our sugar cookie dipped in yellow colored white chocolate with a yummy fudge smiley face

Iced Sugar Cookies starts at $3.19

Sweet sugar cookie dipped in colored chocolate and artistically decorated that vary with the season from sports to animals, and most things in between. Contact us to customize our cookie for your special occasion!

Almond Macarons $29.50/pound

Our recipe has been around for generations, made from almond paste, egg whites and sugar

Large Cookies $2.19

Chocolate chip, M&M, oatmeal raisin, rainbow sprinkle and peanut butter

Individual Desserts

Cake Pops starts at $2.29

chocolate or vanilla cake with decorations that vary thru the year

Cake Shots starts at $2.19

Assortment of cakes and fillings in a shot glass complete with a mini spoon

Caracas $7.29

Mocha buttercream between layers of delicate chocolate soufflé cake that is spritzed with coffee liqueur, finished with chocolate glaze and chocolate covered mocha beans

Chocolate Éclair $4.39

Light and airy éclair shell filled with scratch-made custard and topped with chocolate icing

Fudge Cup $3.99

Vanilla buttercream sandwiched between yellow cake and iced in fudge

Fudge Square $5.79

Chocolate soufflé cake filled with chocolate French buttercream, rolled in chocolate sprinkles, capped with fudge icing, and a chocolate diamond

Midnight Rose $5.69

Chocolate soufflé cake lined with a thin layer of ganache and chocolate buttercream, dipped in chocolate, topped with French buttercream, and a fudge rose

Cake Slices

Carrot Cake Slice $5.69

Walnuts, carrots, apples, and raisins join flavorful carrot cake, filled with cream cheese and iced with French buttercream

Chocolate Glaze Cake Slice $5.69

Chocolate soufflé cake filled with French buttercream and enveloped in chocolate glaze

French Vanilla Cake Slice $5.69

Light yellow soufflé cake with French buttercream filling and icing

German Chocolate Cake Slice $5.69

alternating layers of coconut-pecan filling and fudge between layers of delicate chocolate soufflé, iced with fudge, and topped with coconut-pecan filling

Lemon Cake Slice $5.69

yellow soufflé cake filled with lemon curd and iced in lemon French buttercream

Marzipan Cake Slice $5.69

yellow soufflé cake filled with Bavarian cream and covered in marzipan

Raspberry Cake Slice $5.69

Yellow soufflé cake lined with raspberry preserve on top of a thin layer of vanilla buttercream, iced in raspberry French buttercream

Red Velvet Cake Slice $5.69

Rich red velvet cake, with silky cream cheese filling and iced with French buttercream

Breakfast Items

Coffee Cake Strips $10.69 – 15.29

Almond, apple, apple strudel, apricot, blueberry, cardamom, cheese, cheese with chocolate chips, cherry, cherry strudel, chocolate chip, cinnamon melt-away, pecan, raisin, raspberry, streusel, and Swedish flop strip

Round Coffee Cakes $13.29 – 16.99

Almond ring, apple cinnamon, apricot-lemon, Bavarian twirl, butter ring, caramel pecan crunch, cherry cheese, pizza, raspberry-lemon, and streusel

Individual Danish $2.39

Almond, apple, apricot, blueberry, cheese, cherry, cinnamon, custard, pecan, plain, raisin, raspberry, raspberry swirl, and streusel

Donuts $1.89 - $2.39

Buttermilk, chocolate long john, chocolate, cider, cinnamon sugar, cinnamon twirl, coconut, custard Bismark, double chocolate, glazed long john, glazed, plain, powdered sugar, raspberry Bismark, and sprinkle

Donut Holes $7.20 per dozen

Plain, cinnamon, powdered sugar, chocolate dipped and glazed dipped

Muffins $2.49

Apple, blueberry, chocolate-chocolate chip, chocolate chip, cranberry, lemon poppy-seed, morning glory (carrot), and pumpkin (seasonal)

French Raisin Roll $4.79

Scratch-made custard rolled into croissant dough, sprinkled with raisins with icing or plain

Scones $3.09

Biscuit like pastry packed with assorted fruits or baking chips with various toppings 

Our Flavors:

Cinnamon, Blueberry, chocolate chip, harvest (dried apricot, dried cranberries, raisins and a sugary glaze)

Biscotti $2.69

Twice baked almond cookie partially dipped in chocolate, perfect for dunking in coffee

Croissant $3.39

Light, buttery and flakey

Filled Croissants 4.59

Ham & Cheese, Spinach & Feta, Chocolate, and Almond

Gourmet Cinnamon Buns (Saturdays) $4.29

Rolled dough spread with a sweet cinnamon mixture and iced in glaze

Mini Pecan Rolls $15.60 per dozen

Bite sized cinnamon roll, coated in caramel, and topped with pecans

Ham and Cheese Quiche $18.95

Our flaky pie crust filled with a savory egg custard, loaded with ham and cheddar cheese

Spinach & Mushroom Quiche $18.95

Our flaky pie crust filled with a savory egg custard, loaded with spinach, mushrooms and cheddar cheese

Sweet Treats

Brownies $1.59

Decadent chocolate-y, cake-y brownie frosted with scrumptious fudge icing


sugar cookie crust, filled with blueberry, cherry, apple or peach with a lattice sugar cookie top

6" $10.89

8" $13.89

Crunch Cup $2.79

Fluffy yellow cake encrusted with toasted coconut and ensconced in a sugary glaze

Kolacky $.99

Puffy pastry made with sour cream generously topped with assorted fruit fillings or sweetened cream cheese and lightly sprinkled with powdered sugar

Palmier $3.09

Light, crunchy, buttery pastry made from thin layers of flakey puff pastry, shaped into a palm leaf, and sprinkled with sugar.

Palmier with Chocolate 3.69

Our palmier with the edges dipped in chocolate

Pop Tart $3.09

Flakey pastry pocket filled with raspberry preserve, and then frosted with sweet sugar icing

Swedish Pretzel

Puff pastry twisted with cookie dough, showered with crystallized sugar and your choice of toasted almonds or plain
Plain $3.09
With Toasted Almonds $3.69

Turnover $3.09

Buttery puff pastry brimming with apple or cherry pie filling and drizzled with sugary icing

Pineapple Upside Down Cup $4.39

Buttery cake that gets baked on top of a layer of pineapple slices and cherries in a brown sugar-butter mixture, and when it gets flipped over after baking, the sweet syrup infuses the pineapple upside down cake with extra flavor.


Fruit Pies with Double Crust

Apple, Blueberry, Cherry, Peach
8" $15.99
9" $17.99

Fruit Pies with Dutch Crust (fruit pie topped with streusel)

8" $16.99
9" $18.99

Cream Pies

Banana Cream, Coconut Cream, Boston Cream, Key Lime, Lemon Meringue

8" $16.99
9" $18.99

French Silk

8" $17.99

Seasonal Pies

Mince Pie

8" $17.99
9" $20.09

Pecan Pie

8" $20.09
9" $22.09

Pumpkin Pie

8" $15.99
9" $17.99

Strawberry Rhubarb Pie

8" $16.99
9" $18.99

Taffy Apple Pie

Apple pie topped with buttery streusel and drizzled with caramel

8" $17.99
9" $20.09

Cake Menu

Cake Options

Carrot, devil’s food, funfetti, marble, rainbow (colored yellow cake), red velvet, yellow and white


Specialty Fillings

Bavarian Cream, Cannoli,  Custard, and German Chocolate 

Preserve Fillings

Apricot, Raspberry and Strawberry

Fruit Fillings

Blueberry pie, cherry pie, fresh banana, fresh strawberry buttercream (buttercream with chopped strawberry pieces), fresh strawberry, and lemon curd

Icing Fillings

buttercream, chocolate buttercream, cream cheese, French buttercream,  fudge, mousse, and whipped cream


Buttercream, chocolate buttercream, chocolate mousse, chocolate whipped cream, cream cheese, fudge, fondant, French buttercream, ganache, German chocolate, marzipan, whipped cream, and white chocolate mousse


(can be added to buttercream, French buttercream, and mousse)

Almond, amaretto, blueberry, caramel, cherry, cinnamon, coffee/mocha, lemon, lime, marshmallow, mint/peppermint, orange, peanut butter, raspberry, and strawberry


(can be added to buttercream or  French buttercream)

Coconut flakes, Florentine pieces, and Oreo Pieces

2010 Central Street, Evanston, IL |  Tues – Sat 7:30am-4pm | 847-328-1200
© Tag's Bakery