2010 Central Street, Evanston, IL
|
Tuesday - Thursday  7:30am-3pm
Friday + Saturday 7:30am-4pm
Sunday 8:00am-1pm
|
847-328-1200

Thanksgiving 2025

Turkey Cake

$42.00

Our 6" turkey cake is the perfect additions to your feast! Choice of yellow or devil's food cake, filled with pumpkin mousse, this cake features a flock of feathers made from chocolate and a friendly turkey face

Pie Cake

Yellow or Devil's Food cake, filled with your choice of either cherry or apple pie filling, completed with buttercream piped to resemble pie filling peeking through pie crust lattices.

Parker House Rolls

$11.19

Soft, buttery dinner rolls sold by the dozen.

Pumpkin Pie

$17.39

Enjoy a rich, creamy pumpkin pie crafted from Tag's original recipe, made with fresh ingredients and aromatic spices. Perfect for holidays and celebrations, it delivers authentic fall flavor and handcrafted quality.

Turkey Donut

$4.39

A delightful combination of our scrumptious cake donut topped with a donut hole decorated with a cute turkey face. We then artfully drizzle it with a luscious and enchanting multicolor glaze and add the perfect finishing touch with a charming candy corn beak.

Mini Pilgrim Cupcake

$3.19

Featuring a delectable Oreo cookie brim, topped with a miniature Rolo hat and your choice of mouth-watering yellow or chocolate cake. Each cake is generously bathed in rich, velvety smooth chocolate ganache, and then expertly frosted with your preferred buttercream or fudge icing. To top it all off, we sprinkle festive holiday confetti on this […]

Apple Pie

$17.39 - $18.49

Experience the true essence of homemade goodness with our signature Apple Pie! We use the finest apples and roll them in a luscious blend of brown sugar and cinnamon, packing every bite with irresistible flavor. Nestled between our perfectly flaky pie crusts made from scratch.

Turkey Cookie

$3.69

Indulge in our delightful turkey-shaped sugar cookie, generously coated in smooth, velvety chocolate and beautifully adorned with vibrant, eye-catching decorations to resemble a charming, festive turkey

Pumpkin Pie Squares

$4.69

Our delicious pumpkin pie in individual servings, cut into perfect squares just for you!

Mince Pie

$19.59

Our mince filling is carefully crafted using only the finest ingredients, including freshly pressed apple cider, premium brandy, plump raisins, zesty candied orange, diced crisp apples, and our own signature blend of warm spices. Each mouthwatering bite of our mince pie is a culinary adventure, bursting with incredible flavor and unrivaled homemade goodness.

Pecan Pie

$21.89

The pecan pie is a Southern original that offers a combination of sweetness and nuttiness. Made from high-quality ingredients, every slice is an exquisite experience that speaks of the love and care that has gone into perfecting the recipe. This pecan pie is sure to delight!

Turkey Cupcake

$4.39

Delicious yellow or chocolate cake, generously frosted with heavenly chocolate buttercream icing, adorned with a delightful fudge face and wings, and perfected with a scrumptious chocolate tail sprinkled with festive and flavorful sprinkles

Turkey Cake Pop

$3.49

Yellow cake dipped in chocolate, finished with a turkey face.

Cherry Pie

$17.39 - $18.49

Savor  the scrumptious fusion of tart cherries and flaky pie crust in every bite. Our luscious cherry filling, made with juicy, ripe cherries, is sandwiched between two layers of flaky, golden-brown pie crust, creating the perfect balance of sweet and tangy flavors. Whether served warm or cold, this irresistible dessert is perfect for Thanksgiving

Taffy Apple Pie

$19.59

Our mouthwatering apple pie, baked to perfection with a delectable streusel topping and adorned with a luscious caramel drizzle. Each bite is a heavenly combination of sweet, tangy apples and crunchy, buttery streusel, perfectly complemented by the rich, velvety caramel. This dessert is sure to become your new favorite!

Cream Pies

$18.49

Banana, lemon, or coconut, both made with our farm-fresh milk and egg custard, baked in a delectable cookie crust and covered with freshly whipped cream.

French Silk Pie

$19.59

Enjoy the velvety richness of the chocolate as it melts in your mouth, complemented by the creamy decadence of the whipped cream. The delicate chocolate shavings add an elegant touch and make every spoonful a truly delightful experience.

Lemon Meringue Pie

$18.49

Mouthwatering cookie crust generously filled with a velvety homemade lemon curd. Complete with a lusciously light and airy meringue topping, delicately browned to perfection.

Tuesday - Saturday
7:30 am - 4 pm
© Tag's Bakery